Sooner Soulmates No More: Billy Bowman & Jayda Coleman End Fairytale Romance
By Natalie Archer | SportsLife Weekly | April 6, 2025
NORMAN, OKLAHOMA – Just sixteen months after lighting up social media with their New Year’s Eve engagement, University of Oklahoma’s power couple—football standout Billy Bowman and softball superstar Jayda Coleman—have confirmed their breakup, sending shockwaves through the collegiate sports world.
Once seen as the epitome of young athletic love, their split marks the end of an era for Sooners fans who had followed the couple’s journey from high school sweethearts to college icons. Their relationship was not only high-profile but also symbolic—a picture of balance, passion, and mutual understanding between two elite student-athletes navigating fame, expectations, and personal growth.
But behind the touchdowns, home runs, and Instagram-perfect posts, cracks had begun to form. Sources close to the pair describe a slow unraveling that began months ago and culminated in an emotional and “respectful but firm” decision to go their separate ways.
—
FROM FAIRYTALE TO FALLING OUT
Their story began like something out of a movie. Both from Texas, Bowman and Coleman met during regional recruiting events in high school. They became inseparable after arriving in Norman, quickly emerging as two of the most decorated athletes in their programs.
“He was the heartbeat of the defense, and she was the soul of the softball team,” said OU athletic director Lisa Redman. “You didn’t say ‘Billy’ without thinking of Jayda. And vice versa.”
Publicly, everything seemed perfect. Their engagement announcement—set against a backdrop of fireworks at Lake Thunderbird—garnered over 1.2 million views on TikTok and was shared by ESPN, SportsCenter, and even USA Softball. But beneath the celebration, those close to them sensed something different.
“It was fast,” said one teammate who requested anonymity. “They loved each other, but they were both becoming different people. Billy started thinking more about the NFL. Jayda was getting calls about the Olympic team. They had dreams, but those dreams were starting to pull in opposite directions.”
—
DIFFERENT DIRECTIONS, DIFFERENT DEMANDS
Bowman, 22, has been training for the 2025 NFL Draft, where many analysts project him as a second-round pick. His preparation has taken him to Arizona and then Florida, where he’s been working with top trainers. Coleman, 23, meanwhile, has been laser-focused on defending her fourth Women’s College World Series title while also juggling USA Softball commitments and NIL obligations.
“It was hard to even find a time to FaceTime,” said another friend. “They were constantly missing each other.”
According to sources close to the couple, the final conversation happened two weeks ago during a quiet weekend in Norman. They met for coffee—no entourage, no photographers, no glam. Just two people who had grown up together, now realizing they were growing apart.
“Jayda was calm. Billy was emotional,” said someone who witnessed the meeting. “There were tears, hugs, but no yelling. Just a mutual understanding that love alone wasn’t enough to hold it together anymore.”
—
THE STATEMENTS
Both Coleman and Bowman posted individual messages to their Instagram accounts Sunday morning.
> “Sometimes the hardest decisions are the ones made with love. Billy will always have a place in my heart. I’m proud of the man he’s becoming. This isn’t goodbye, just a shift in the journey.” – Jayda Coleman
> “Jayda is and always will be one of the most incredible people I’ve known. Our love story was real. But we’re on different paths now, and that’s okay. I’ve got nothing but respect and love for her.” – Billy Bowman
The comments were flooded with support from fellow athletes, celebrities, and fans.
—
THE REACTIONS
The reaction from fans was immediate—and intense. On Reddit and X (formerly Twitter), hashtags like #BillyAndJayda and #SoonerSplit began trending by mid-morning.
“I thought they’d make it,” wrote @sooners4life. “They looked so happy. But I guess careers come first.”
Others took a more reflective tone.
“These are two young people under insane pressure. They gave us great memories. Let’s wish them the best instead of trying to dissect every detail.” – @collegesportsqueen
Even OU Head Coach Brent Venables commented briefly during a press conference:
> “Breakups happen. What matters is that they’re both good people, and they’ve got great futures ahead. They supported each other through a lot.”
—
WHAT’S NEXT?
Bowman continues training for the draft in Miami and is expected to attend the NFL Combine later this month. Scouts are high on his athleticism and leadership skills, which many attribute, in part, to his relationship with Coleman.
Coleman is preparing for the upcoming NCAA postseason while also keeping an eye on the 2025 Olympics. Rumors have surfaced that she may sign a high-profile endorsement deal with a major athletic brand this summer.
As for the engagement ring? Sources say Jayda returned it privately without drama.
“They both wanted to keep it classy,” said a mutual friend. “No drama. No dragging each other on social media. Just love, real love, that didn’t last forever.”
—
CLOSING A CHAPTER
It’s the kind of story that reminds people that behind the highlight reels, these are just young people trying to figure it out. Fame, ambition, and youth can be an intoxicating mix—and sometimes, even the most promising love stories come to an end.
Billy and Jayda’s relationship gave fans something to root for off the field. Now, as they head into the next phases of their lives—separately—those same fans are rooting for their success just the same.
Whatever comes next, their impact on Oklahoma, and on each other, is undeniable.
–
