Over the past decade, Everton has seen an array of exceptional talent pass through its ranks, yet the club has not progressed as one might expect. The sight of superstars and leading figures in their positions gracing Goodison Park, only to leave the Toffees in a worse state, is puzzling.
The primary reason for this decline is the ineptitude of Farhad Moshiri and the failures within the scouting system under his leadership. Despite possessing valuable assets, the club struggled to build a sustainable future. However, the arrival of Dan Friedkin promises a departure from this troubled era, aiming for a more sustainable model.
In pursuit of this new era of prosperity, Everton can no longer indulge in the luxuries of the past. However, there remains one player that most Evertonians dream of seeing play for them once more, particularly because so few had the opportunity to witness his brilliance live. This player is James Rodriguez.
Among those advocating for Rodriguez’s return is Everton’s Portuguese goalkeeper Joao Virginia. He took to Instagram, urging the Colombian star to return to Goodison Park. Rodriguez, now 33, had a brief but impactful stint at Everton under Carlo Ancelotti before being pushed out by Rafa Benitez when Ancelotti left for Madrid. Despite his departure, Rodriguez had no intentions of leaving.
Virginia’s comment was brief but heartfelt. After Rodriguez’s run to the Copa America final, Virginia wrote, “Amazing brother, come back.” This sentiment resonates with many Evertonians who missed seeing Rodriguez play live due to the pandemic. However, despite the widespread desire to see him in the royal blue again, there is no place for a player of Rodriguez’s style in Sean Dyche’s system.
Rodriguez, who has spent much of his career playing behind the striker or on the right wing, would face competition from Jack Harrison and Abdoulaye Doucoure for those positions. While the comparison might seem absurd given Rodriguez’s illustrious career, it underscores the difference in playing styles and fit within Dyche’s philosophy.
During his year at Goodison Park, Rodriguez seldom engaged in defensive duties, benefiting from Ancelotti’s system that allowed him to roam freely without much defensive responsibility. This freedom enabled him to pop up in various positions, creating significant impact. However, Dyche’s system requires all players, including right wingers and attacking midfielders, to contribute defensively. His formation often shifts to a 4-4-2 out of possession to cover more ground and maintain a solid defensive structure.
Thus, while the return of James Rodriguez would be a dream for many Everton fans, it is unlikely to materialize under the current management. The club must focus on building a team that aligns with Dyche’s hard-working philosophy, ensuring long-term success and stability.
